🥛

Eggnog

Dairy

A rich, creamy holiday drink made from eggs, milk, cream, and sugar, often flavored with nutmeg. Used as a beverage and in baking (French toast, cakes, cookies).

3 substitutes

Substitutes

Cream, Fluid, Half and Half

1:1

For baking, use half and half with added sugar, nutmeg, and vanilla to mimic eggnog flavor. Add 1 tsp nutmeg and 1 tsp vanilla per cup.

✅Best for: baking, French toast, puddings

⚠️Not for: drinking as a beverage

vegetarian

Milk, Whole, 3.25% Milkfat

1:1

Use whole milk with a beaten egg yolk, sugar, and nutmeg to make a quick homemade eggnog substitute. Less rich but captures the flavor profile.

✅Best for: baking, beverages

⚠️Not for:

vegetarian

Milk, Canned, Condensed, Sweetened

1:2

Dilute condensed milk 1:1 with whole milk, then add nutmeg and vanilla. Creates a thick, sweet, creamy substitute for baking.

✅Best for: baking, desserts

⚠️Not for: beverages (too sweet)

vegetarian

← Back to all ingredients